‘The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes’ (2023): The Franchise’s Rawest Games Lift a Meandering Prequel

A fascinating villain study and the franchise’s rawest Games make this prequel worth watching, even if its long final hour keeps circling the same ideas.

Share
‘The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes’ (2023): The Franchise’s Rawest Games Lift a Meandering Prequel
© Lionsgate

I skipped The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes on purpose back in 2023. I didn’t have time to rewatch the original four films first, and I really wanted to before jumping back into Panem. All I knew was that it follows a young Coriolanus Snow decades before he becomes Katniss’ tormentor. I went in completely blind.

Knowing where Snow ends up is what makes this interesting. Coriolanus starts as a genuinely sweet kid, the last hope of a fallen family hiding its hunger behind good manners. Since we know who he becomes, every kind gesture carries a question mark from the first scene. The movie treats the making of a tyrant as a pile-up of small choices rather than one big snap: a rule bent, a secret kept, a friend weighed against a future. Blyth (Benediction) plays both sides well, charming enough to earn some trust and guarded enough that you never fully give it. Sejanus Plinth (Josh Andrés Rivera, West Side Story), the classmate who actually acts on his conscience, shows the road Snow could still take, and I really liked him. I wanted much more of Tigris (Hunter Schafer, Cuckoo), who barely gets anything to do. Outside Snow’s arc, though, the themes felt redundant after four films that already covered them.

The Games are the real surprise. This is only the tenth edition, so there are no elaborate arenas or high-tech traps, just a bombed-out stadium and kids with crude weapons they barely know how to use. That rawness works in the movie’s favor. Deaths hit harder, and the action feels more desperate. Some stretches are seriously suspenseful, right up to a pretty cool ending. Unless you count the Capitol streets of Mockingjay – Part 2, a real war rather than a TV show, these might be the franchise’s best Games. Dr. Volumnia Gaul (Viola Davis, Fences) and Lucky Flickerman (Jason Schwartzman, Asteroid City) steal every scene, making these roles their own. Production design and costumes remain two of the saga’s standout departments, from the Capitol’s retro TV studio to Lucy Gray Baird’s rainbow dress.

Lucy Gray herself is trickier. Rachel Zegler (Snow White) is a star with a voice like an angel and real emotional range. The character is a different story. Her accent sounds off next to everyone else from District 12, heavier in some scenes and back to normal in others — and I’m not usually one to notice that stuff. I like the songs themselves. There are just too many, and the film starts cashing in on having cast Zegler instead of figuring out who Lucy Gray is. The romance works while the Games are running, but with a full hour left to develop it, it never gets past "good enough".

That last hour is what really holds it back. At 157 minutes, this plays like several movies sewn together, and the title cards splitting it into three acts only underline it. The franchise once stretched one book into two films, and now it crams three movies into one. I don’t mind losing momentum if what follows is fascinating, but the final act keeps circling the same ideas while a very predictable ending waits on the horizon. Winks like a nod to the plant Katniss is named after, or yet another round of “The Hanging Tree,” stand in for real reveals. The couple’s story wraps up in a rushed manner that never feels fully justified, and Snow’s turn is convincing but not as shocking as the buildup promised. Dean Casca Highbottom (Peter Dinklage, Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri) is fine, yet his most interesting side gets saved for one late conversation. For the future President Snow, I expected something far more visceral than loose threads left mysterious on purpose.

I like it more than Mockingjay – Part 1. The villain study, the rawest Games of the saga, and a terrific cast make the first two acts worth it, before a meandering final hour drifts toward an ending everyone saw coming. I went back and forth, but it lands fourth in my ranking: Catching Fire, Mockingjay – Part 2, The Hunger Games, this prequel, and Mockingjay – Part 1.

Rating: B-