‘The Hunger Games: Mockingjay – Part 1’ (2014): Jennifer Lawrence Elevates an Uneven First Half of the Finale

The franchise trades the arena for a war of images, and Jennifer Lawrence leads a stacked cast that keeps this padded first half of the finale worth watching.

Share
‘The Hunger Games: Mockingjay – Part 1’ (2014): Jennifer Lawrence Elevates an Uneven First Half of the Finale
© Lionsgate

Of the four original Hunger Games movies, this is the one that left the faintest mark on my memory, if it left any at all. I did know it suffered from the Part 1/Part 2 syndrome, the Hollywood habit of splitting a final book in two (a trend that has thankfully faded), so a complete story was never on the table. After Catching Fire, my favorite of the franchise so far, I just hoped for a solid watch that would set up the finale well.

The split hurts, and I felt it early. The Hunger Games: Mockingjay – Part 1 has no real beginning or end, only the slow work of moving pieces into place, and it stops right as things get interesting. To fill the time, it repeats itself. The same debate about whether Katniss can be the face of the revolution keeps coming back, and every visit to a ruined district plays at the same somber pitch, so 123 minutes feel heavier than they should. Without the Games, action is scarce, too. The gray, underground look of District 13 doesn’t help, although I get why a war bunker looks like one. It's just that all that concrete and dim lighting adds to the drag.

The story it does tell, though, is fascinating. This is a war fought with cameras as the rebels shoot “propos” to rally the districts while the Capitol answers by parading a fragile Peeta on live TV. It’s the sharpest the franchise has been about image-making, and I never found it shallow. The best idea is that Katniss can’t act. Hand her a scripted line in front of a green screen, and she’s hopeless in one of the film’s few genuinely funny scenes. Put her in front of wounded civilians in District 8, and her anger becomes exactly the footage the rebels wanted. Her honesty is what makes her useful, so being authentic doesn’t stop her from being used. Jennifer Lawrence (Mother!) nails both modes, stiff when performing and raw when it’s real. She spends a lot of the movie watching events unfold on screens, and that never bothered me. A symbol is something other people consume.

It’s also a film about damaged people, and it doesn’t rush past that. It opens with Katniss curled up in a corner, barely holding together, and the trauma never leaves her. Everyone who survived the arena is broken in some way, from a withdrawn Finnick (Sam Claflin, The Nightingale) to Peeta, who looks more hollow in each broadcast. Hutcherson (The Kids Are All Right) does his best work of the series with barely any screen time. Philip Seymour Hoffman (Capote), in one of his final roles, plays Plutarch as an image-maker who simply switched clients, and Julianne Moore (Still Alice) is icy as Coin, a leader who needs Katniss but never quite trusts her. Elizabeth Banks (Pitch Perfect), Woody Harrelson (Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri), Donald Sutherland (Ordinary People) and newcomer Natalie Dormer (Rush) all deliver. Gale (Liam Hemsworth, The Last Song) finally gets something to do, and the love triangle reaches its point of no return, even if it could’ve gotten there a movie earlier.

Francis Lawrence (I Am Legend) keeps the tension up even when little happens, and the film is surprisingly dark for a PG-13 blockbuster, from the skeletons of District 12 to a hospital bombing that hits hard. Its best sequence is “The Hanging Tree,” a song Katniss sings almost to herself that the rebels turn into an anthem, intercut with an attack on a dam — propaganda, grief, and a shared voice in one scene. The climactic rescue is well staged, but it didn’t land as hard as expected since its final turn isn’t that crazy.

Half a movie is still half a movie, and this one drags more than it should. I enjoyed it well enough, though. The propaganda angle, Jennifer Lawrence, and a stacked supporting cast kept me invested, and as a bridge to the finale, it does its job. Now it’s on the second half to make the wait worth it.

Rating: B-